Good news from Africa

I was heartened by the news on Friday that Sub-Saharan Africa is leading the global decline in new HIV cases. It seems that countries in this region have seen an infection rate drop of 25% apparently due to better education and preventative measures.

A few years ago, I was commissioned by Positive Lives to spend a month on the Rwandan/Burundian border looking at the lives of those affected. The Rwandan government had made great strides in their efforts to get people tested and educated about the risks but crucially about how to live and cope with the illness. The work won the Amnesty International Award in 2006.

As I said at the time, it seemed to me that the Rwandese, packed tightly into their borders, had learned the real meaning of forgiveness and acceptance.

Rwanda - Kibileze - Saidi Ruhimbana (40) comforts his wife Anastasie Hwamerera (40). Both have AIDS but Anastasie is very sick. In order to pay for medicine for their treatment they have spent their savings and taken some of their children out of school. Saidi was formerly a builder but is now too weak to lift anything heavy

Rwanda - Kibileze - Theogene Niyongana gives a lecture on HIV and AIDS to a group of people waiting to be tested for the virus at Kibayi Health Centre. By addressing their status, sufferers learn how to increase their life expectancy.

Rwanda - Kibayi - A woman receives her AIDS test result with shock at Kibayi Health Centre. The result is 'undetermined' which means she will have to be re-tested

Rwanda - Kibileze - A woman is given the results of her HIV test at Kibayi Health centre

Rwanda - Kibileze - Jean Pierre Sibomana (31) who is HIV positive, laughs with his wife and children (all HIV negative) about his wedding photographs. Kanage village

Rwanda - Kibileze - Teacher Potamienne Komezusenge (37) plays with her youngest child. She contracted HIV from her husband who died of the diesase and is buried in the back garden under a wooden cross. She says "As long as I feel strong, I feel OK emotionally... sometimes there is stigma here... but the biggest problem is money". Kibileze, Rwanda

Rwanda - Kibileze - Emmanuel Singizumakiza, a health educator shows a boy how to use a condom

Rwanda - Kibileze - Narcisse, who is HIV positive and the president of his local AIDS Association - Girimpuhwe ('Have compassion') - prays with his family at home at dawn before they start work in the fields. Kibileze, Rwanda

Rwanda - Kibileze - Narcisse, who is HIV positive and the president of his local AIDS Association - Girimpuhwe ('Have compassion') works in his fields

Without labouring the point, it was a pleasure to be taking pictures that weren’t simply showing people dying. I see so many photographers making work that purports to show an explanation of a subject but actually is little more than graphic cliche of a situation. That, at a time of crisis for visual journalism, isn’t enough. It isn’t enough to simply point a camera at someone and say ‘how terrible’. It says much that everybody has a camera and thinks that they have a right to call themselves a journalist by photographing the nearest horror without context or understanding. We earn a dubious and tenuous ‘right’ to report the world to itself by entering into a dialogue with it: an impossible covenant with a subject that tries not to perpetuate stereotype, easy answers or sloppy conclusions. It isn’t enough to go and photograph beggars on the streets of India for example to further our own purposes under the cover of journalism. We had better have a damn good reason to invade people’s spaces and lives. If you need an example of what is decent and committed about documentary practice look no further than that of my former Network Photographer colleague, Gideon Mendel who has spent more than a decade committed to the portrayal of HIV/AIDS in exactly the way I am talking about.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

8 Responses to “Good news from Africa”

  1. duckrabbit Says:

    Thoughtful and though provoking stuff … both the photos and the thinking behind them, which makes all the difference.

  2. sang Says:

    Really nice pictures,sure transport you there

  3. JF Leroy, ‘I am listening’ | duckrabbit - we produce photofilms Says:

    […] photographer Stuart Freedman recently nailed this idea in a blog post: ‘I see so many photographers making work that purports to show an explanation of a subject […]

  4. Sharon Van Lieu Says:

    Gorgeous, meaningful work and your last paragraph is one that all photographers (including myself) need to read.

    Thank you,

    Sharon

  5. Pointing the camera isn’t enough | dvafoto Says:

    […] I see so many photographers making work that purports to show an explanation of a subject but actually is little more than graphic cliche of a situation. That, at a time of crisis for visual journalism, isn’t enough. It isn’t enough to simply point a camera at someone and say ‘how terrible’. -Stuart Freedman […]

  6. It isn’t enough to simply point a camera | Photography @ Coronado High School Says:

    […] themselves a journalist by photographing the nearest horror without context or understanding.” – Stuart Freedman addthis_url = […]

  7. “It isn’t enough to simply point a camera”, sobre fotoperiodismo. Says:

    […] Y aquí está el porqué. […]

  8. Jennifer P Says:

    I’m entering my 2nd year in the professional photography field and am discovering new things all the time, including this article – thanks for this site. Jen